Press J to jump to the feed. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts

Another Good Reason Not to Shoot Nukes at Asteroids

73% Upvoted
This thread is archived
New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast
Sort by
level 1

We would end up blowing up Bruce Willis along with the asteroid.

level 1
1 point · 8 years ago

Initially I thought "Ha ha, very funny OP. Firing a giant phallic object at a butt-shaped asteroid." /rollseyes

Apparently that's not why the OP posted the article :/

level 1

Science reporters...please stop making silly statements in your story...

But if we are faced with a civilization-ending asteroid appearing out of nowhere, like the one that wiped out the dinosaurs, I'd be the first to suggest assembling the world's nuclear arsenal.

It didn't appear out of no where; dinosaurs didn't have 1000 telescopes and satellites staring at the sky. And if they did, please tell me about it, because that is awesome.

level 1
1 point · 8 years ago · edited 8 years ago

If an asteroid is small enough to keep the damage localized to a city we probably wouldn't see it anyway.

test it for yourself

level 2
0 points · 8 years ago

An asteroid of maybe only 100 feet in diameter can cause an aerial burst of +100 kilotons. That's a medium sized nuke a few miles above the ground. It would flatten a small city and we wouldn't see it coming. :)

level 3

Surely, you used the wrong bracket for your smiley face ":( "

level 1
0 points · 8 years ago

If asteroids are reassembling themselves after you nuke them, you're not using enough nukes.

Community Details





This community is a place to share and discuss new scientific research. Read about the latest advances in astronomy, biology, medicine, physics, social science, and more. Find and submit new publications and popular science coverage of current research.

Create Post
r/science Rules
Must be peer-reviewed research
No second-hand summaries, reviews, or reposts
No editorialized, sensationalized or biased titles
Research must be <6 months old
No off-topic comments
No jokes or memes
No abusive or offensive comments
No anecdotal comments
Not scientific or dismissive of established work
No medical advice
r/Science Ask Me Anything

We've discontinued our regular 'Ask Me Anything' Q&A series. You can view all the previous AMAs at the link below.

Verified User Program

Do you have a college degree in a scientific field? Get flair in r/science to indicate your expertise!

Related Communities

133,923 subscribers


16,288,252 subscribers


36,599 subscribers

Cookies help us deliver our Services. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More.